Published On: Tue, Feb 14th, 2017

Immigration woes: Too much emotion, Too few facts, too little border security

carlos-barbieri-retrato-122x150-1By Carlo Barbieri


The debate over immigration rules, and, in particular, the number of and need for deportations, continues to rage in this nation that remains sorely divided about the matter. Clearly, the issue deserves more and better scrutiny, not couched in ideological hysteria, but, rather, in the full light of day – and within the framework of factual data.

We have long deliberated this topic, and now is as good a time as any to continue the search for solutions.

First of all, it should be noted that the period of time in which we recorded the most deportations in the US was during the term of President Obama. A total of 2.5 million immigrants were returned to their native countries during his administration.

For the sake of our discussion, let us take a look at the 2016 numbers, which show that 240,255 deportations took place.

A total of 65,332 were people who had been apprehended and deported in the United States. Of these, 60,318 had already burdened themselves with a criminal record.

Another 174,923 deportees were arrested at or near the border. Of these, 78,351 had criminal records.

(It should be noted that 2,057 of these criminals were gang members.)

If so many of these deportees were criminals – in other words, people imprisoned at correctional facilities in the interior of the country — and 58% were considered criminals after being taken into custody at the border, the search for improvements to border security and better regulation of deportations cannot be heaped at the doorway of America’s  “new” Trump-led government.

It would be unthinkable for a government not to protect its population from this veritable invasion of lawbreakers. Only with effective security that can stop illegals will it be possible to obtain a fair amnesty for those who have come to the US to work and seek a better life for their families.

We understand that, according to official data, about 4% of US residents are undocumented. Of these, about two-thirds have been living here for more than 10 years without causing problems for their neighbors, the local constabulary or the judicial system.

On the other hand, it should be noted that in order to deport all immigrants, it would cost around $600 billion. This would not only an incalculable financial horror show, but a logistical nightmare. It is an alternative that would overtax this nation from a financial and manpower point of view. And even if it cleared away a majority of illegal aliens, the impact would set this nation back severely.

As far as terrorists are concerned, there are about 1.2 million people on the list of potential suspects. Of this number, about 70,000 are on America’s “No Fly List.”

To remove these suspects from the US, each would have to be escorted by more than 20 law enforcement agents. This is the obvious rationale for keeping terrorists and suspected terrorist from entering the country in the first place.

It is not just the cost of the officers necessary to accompany these dangerous suspects that makes it prohibitive. Terrorists, even a single one surrounded by guards, poses a risk of setting off an attack, either spontaneous or planned, within American borders.

The ability of even new terror recruits to endanger the indigenous American population, and the ever-possible danger that they may obtain false documents with support of people from within the countries that support terrorism or have a strong contingent of terrorist “allies” in their administration, pose a great risk.

I believe that all citizens and residents in the US agree on some points that should be the basis for effective action to enhance the levels of security and remove possibilities of risk in the immigration system:

  • As much as is practicable, deter terrorists, traffickers and other people who put the security and tranquility of people living in the United States in danger;
  • Expel as soon as possible the arrested immigrant criminals, so that our taxes are not used to keep these prisoners in public lockups;
  • Once and for all, improve border safety to limit the costs of dealing with problems caused by additional illegal immigrants;
  • As soon as possible after our borders are secured, seek a solution to regularize the lives of undocumented immigrants within the US who have not caused harm, endangered lives or have criminal records;
  • Create fresh and innovative ways to receive new immigrants from various segments of foreign populations, including retirees and small investors (other than those who are already entitled to enter the US with an E-2 visa); and
  • Urge “internal terrorists” who bring despair and fear to immigrants to reach out to what is good and progressive in America and foster their own personal advantages.

About the Author

- My name is Carlo Barbieri, an entrepreneur, civic activist and a leader of many organizations associated with Brazil. A native of Brazil myself, I am currently the CEO of Oxford Group, a firm composed of many international consulting and trading companies. I am also a founding member of the Brazilian Business Group and founding member and Past President of the Brazil Club. In addition, I serve as a Board member of the Deerfield Chamber of Commerce. I have served as a member of the Florida Chamber of Commerce and the Florida Brazil Partnership. Past President of the Rotary Club – Boca Raton West for the 2014-2015 term, I have also been Vice President and Professor of 2Grow – Human Development. An Ambassador of Barry University in Brazil, I am the former President of the Black Fire Bull Steak House. I have also presided over a number of organizations such as the Brazilian Association of Trading Companies (ABECE), Brazil-China Chamber of Commerce in São Paulo, Brazil-Australia Chamber of Commerce, Brazil-Dominican Republican Chamber of Commerce; director of the Trade Center of the State of São Paulo, Brazilian Association of Freight Forwarders and Brazilian Association of Banks. I was also a local Council member for the Consulate General of Brazil in Miami, for the 2013-2017 term.

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these html tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>